5 Comments
User's avatar
Ari's avatar

" there was a debate about whether IDF soldiers in the West Bank have to fulfil their internationally recognised obligations as a military occupying power or whether they can just waste anyone who they think might be a threat. In reality, IDF soldiers have always been basically immune from prosecution unless they kill someone on the floor on camera, and even then they get 9 months, but this was not good enough for the Right."

It's stuff like this that makes me question your facts in areas I know less about. While it's true that prosecution has been rare, the picture painted here is at odds with what I have heard from people who have actually served, which is that rules of engagement are taken quite seriously, and petty discipline is used to enforce them (which is consistent with few real MAG prosecutions). Let's leave Gaza out of it for a moment, since you are talking about 2016. I just don't think this is an accurate picture at all.

משכיל בינה's avatar

The rules are fairly strict (not stricter than they should be, but strict enough), but if you break them, nothing happens. Feel free to find counter-examples, but you won't because the longest sentence a soldier has got is 21 months for shooting someone point blank in the head. The rules are taken as seriously as the commanding officer wants them to be, no more, no less because if he decides not to do anything, no-one else will.

__browsing's avatar

I can't speak to what the formal rules of engagement are meant to be within the IDF, but the Elor Azaria case seemed like a conspicuously caught-red-handed-off-scott-free example.

https://bennymorris.substack.com/p/presidential-trumpery

Tom Häkkinen's avatar

The online right love to tease leftists for their metaphysical belief in "Magic Dirt". And maybe it's true that Magic Dirt doesn't exist, but it sometimes strikes me that some of your countrymen are doing everything within their power to prove its opposite exists—benighted dirt.

Alban's avatar

The nerdy Biblical/Talmudic exegesis is good. You make it interesting More please!